The difference between the two types of auto insurance agents is the captive agent works on an exclusive contract with one company while the independent agent usually represents several companies. Some advantages to using independent agents include their ability to shop the market for the best possible rates and coverages for your situation.

They are not bound to any one company, therefore their loyalty is to you, not the
insurance company. A captive agent's loyalty is to the insurance company. The
major reason for not providing what you need is the limited scope of products and
choices he or she has to offer. The major disadvantage of an independent agent is
some agents will switch you from company to company, telling you they found a
cheaper rate, when in reality they are looking out for their commission checks. Let
me explain what I mean. Normally, when a policy is written, the agent receives a
commission. When the policy renews, the agent again receives a commission.
The problem is the renewal commission is smaller than the new business commission,
so by switching you from company to company the agent earns a higher commission.

Loyalty, Is There Any?
Most people assume that if they stay with an auto insurance company for a long
time, they will create a loyalty between the insurance company and themselves.
That is true to a minor degree. Many companies do offer programs such as longevity
discounts up to 15%+, for customers insured with the company for X number of
years. However, a majority of the time you're not getting a good rate in those first X
number of years. It's like a jewelry sale where they cut the price in half on an
already overpriced product and after the discount it's still overpriced. The only other
possible advantage for longevity with an insurance company is in the event you
need an underwriting exception for a situation that has occurred. An example of an
exception would be as follows. You purchase an additional vehicle, and when you
request the vehicle be added to your policy, you discover that the speeding citation
you received last year will keep you from getting the best possible rate. Your agent
could request an exception from the company and, if granted, the company overlooks
the citation and gives you the lower rate. This would be expected if you have been
with an insurance company for a long time and your account has been profitable.

However, I've seen cases of long time clients not getting this kind of service because the company decided no more exceptions, leaving the customer out in the cold!
Each company files its rules with the state department of insurance. Anything
they do differently from what is filed is an exception. They don't like to give exceptions but if enough pressure is applied they will. One reason they don't like to give exceptions is they are audited by the insurance department and have to give an
accounting for all exceptions given. In spite of this fact, they do give exceptions to
whomever they wish, whenever they wish.

What you and I consider loyalty to be in a relationship is almost non-existent
in the insurance business. The name of the game now is big business, big dollars
and bottom line results'. It has to be that way because the business of getting your
insurance dollars has become so competitive and changes so rapidly that the days
of loyalty and relationships are a thing of the past. / would say for the most part,
loyalty to you from the insurance company means little to nothing, and should
not be considered as a factor in changing companies

Agent loyalty is quite a different matter. The agent is paid on a commission
only basis, and therefore, is more concerned about your welfare. If you are loyal to
a good agent, that agent will be loyal to you doing all he or she can to service your
account. Agents possessing a loyal attitude probably represent 60% to 70% of all
agents in the business.

Remember, the agent is a puppet of the insurance company and there is very
little he or she can do for you that the insurance company wouldn't allow you to do
without an agent. Also, remember the role of the agent today will become far different
in the future. So again, it's time to look out for yourself and consider acting as
your own agent!

Auto Insurance Comparison rate quotes:

Insweb Compare auto insurance quotes from several different insurance companies instantly.

4Insurance - This company give you an instant quote from an auto insurance company so you can use it for quick comparison.

InsuranceTracker - Take control of your search by finding info on your local auto insurance agents, inquire about their policies and their promotions, and compare. Just select your auto insurance type, enter zip code, and click find. Click Here

InsureCom - have a network of thousands of participating auto insurance agents and companies across the United States. Once you complete the online form, the computer system instantly attempts to match your profile to as many as five top auto insurance companies. Your information is immediately sent to them, they work up their best quotes, and contact you with their rates. Click here to get a free auto insurance quote.

Netquote- Currently over 5,000 insurance agents representing over 100 insurance companies subscribe to NetQuote. Provide you with as many as 5 competitive auto insurance quotes from the nation's auto insurance companies.

Insurance com – Compare up to 4 quotes from multiple Auto Insurance companies.

Direct quote from the auto insurance companies:

21st Century Insurance Company

Electric Insurance

SHOPPING MALL

SHOPPING MALL > DEPARTMENT STORE